Mojo gave it 1 star and calling it a "travesty". Was looking forward to it as well. Meanwhile, what happened to the supposed Kinks reunion I read about ? > Date: Sun, 16 Jan 2011 12:56:39 -0500 > From: bholmes_fm@msn.com > To: audities@smoe.org > Subject: Ray Davies duets album > > I'm a Kinks fan *and* a tribute fan and was looking forward to this > album, but this UK review is pretty brutal - ouch! Hopefully the truth > lies in the middle. > > --- > > Following on from 2009’s The Kinks Choral Collection, on which Ray > Davies rearranged his back catalogue with the Crouch End Festival > Chorus, See My Friends finds him sifting through his songbook once > again, only this time he’s brought Bon Jovi along. > > Yes, it’s a duets album, of the type that veteran artists produce when > they’ve nothing left to prove. Such ventures seldom serve much point > beyond flattering the star with attention from fellow musicians, who in > turn are honoured by association. Plus they sell well. > > Ray Davies doesn’t need to record a soporific version of Tired of > Waiting with Snow Patrol’s Gary Lightbody, any more than Bruce > Springsteen needs to trample the bittersweet Better Things with his > wholly unsuitable bombast. But both were doubtless thrilled by the > opportunity to record with Davies. And that’s just it: these all-star > gatherings are more fun for the artists than they are for the listener. > > Try as one might, it’s impossible to resist comparing these duets > against the hallowed originals, especially when their arrangements > barely differ. The likes of This is Where I Belong with Frank Black > (billed as Black Francis) and Long Way From Home with Lucinda Williams > are pleasant recordings of wonderful songs, but what is their point? > Jackson Browne may be in simpatico with Davies’ unweathered voice on > Waterloo Sunset, but will anyone ever reach for this version over the > magical original? Will they even remember it exists? > > For better or downright ghastly, the most memorable tracks are those on > which the guests imprint themselves. The undoubted highlights are > Mumford & Sons’ folk-gospel medley, Days / This Time Tomorrow, its > arrangement madly ambitious compared with its companions, and Spoon’s > shoegazing treatment of the proto-psychedelic title-track. The late Alex > Chilton sounds genuinely enthused on ‘Til the End of the Day, a song his > old band Big Star covered during the Third/Sister Lovers sessions. > Recorded in 2009, it was the spur for these sessions. > > But the tenderness and wit of Davies’ songs and singing is smothered by > his blunter collaborators. However sincere, Springsteen’s bellowing > simply doesn’t work. Paloma Faith’s Lola is a wretched, over-sung X > Factor throwaway. Metallica’s drilling of You Really Got Me is bar-band > bad. And Jon Bon Jovi and Richie Sambora’s overwrought stadium-rock > assault on Celluloid Heroes is a laughable abomination. > > It’s testament to Davies’ legacy that he emerges from this inessential > project with his dignity intact. > >