Actually, I was referring to Jim Booth's article... Though the RS picks weren't as far off as I thought they'd be with my opinion either... I'd probably not select the Daft Punk.... not that I don't like Daft Punk, but how "live" is it? If we're counting sequencing in the live context I'd say Kraftwerk's Minimum Maximum... I agree with you about Under A Blood Red Sky. Rattle & Hum never moved me that much either. -------------- Original message -------------- From: Sam Smith > As I noted in the comment thread, as much as I love /Rattle & Hum/ I > feel like /Under a Blood Red Sky/ is by far the better choice. I'm not > going to lose sleep either way - since it's /Rolling Stone/ I'm stunned > they even got close. But I suspect I'm not alone in opting for the > earlier record. > > *Well that's the first time that's ever happened. > > I agreed with every single pick he made for generationally segregated best > live albums. > > Good call. > > > > > > > > > -- > > _______________________ > > *Sam Smith* > > *voice: * *303.229.0619 /m * > *aim:* lullabypit > *skype:* docsammy22 > *e-mail:* sam@lullabypit.com > *web:* http://www.lullabypit.com >