1. Well, obviously 2. and 3. yep. you're right. It was a Goffin/King composition, from the Pisces CD, no? (Had to look that one up.) I could have sworn that I've read that it was (at least partially) inspired by PW, but your statement is probably closer to the truth as a direct influence. "Facts are stubborn things", Ben Franklin once said (it was BF, wasn't it?) This site below has some nice tidbits on their CD's with song by song commentary: http://www.thesmileshop.net/monkees.html Bopp. Thanks Man >----- ------- Original Message ------- ----- >From: "Sager, Greg" >To: audities@smoe.org >Sent: Wed, 16 May 2007 04:46:13 > ><From: rob@splitsville.com >To: audities@smoe.org, audities@smoe.org >Subject: >=?US-ASCII?B?UkU6IFJlOiBUaGUgR3JhdGUgRGViYXRl?= >Message-ID: ><20070515230900.34544.qmail@mmm1912.dulles19-verio. >com> > >The studio/Kirshner heard Paperback Writer, knew >they needed a song that >began with a riff, and came back with Pleasant >Valley Sunday. >> > > >1. "Paperback Writer" begins with the *a capella* >chorus, not the riff. > >2. "Paperback Writer" was released in late May (US) >/ early June (UK) of >1966. "Pleasant Valley Sunday" was released as a >pre-album single in >mid-July 1967, well over a year later. The Monkees >put out six other >singles after the release of "Paperback Writer" >before they put out >"Pleasant Valley Sunday", which seems to indicate >that the latter hit >was not designed to fill a need created by the >former. > >3. Don Kirshner and The Monkees parted ways long >before "Pleasant Valley >Sunday" came out. The last Monkees song with which >he was involved was >"A Little Bit Me, A Little Bit You" in the spring >of 1967. The Monkees >actually had quite a bit of creative autonomy by >the time "Pleasant >Valley Sunday" was recorded, so it's not likely >that "the studio" was >dictating terms to them at that point. > >You may be thinking of "Last Train To Clarksville" >rather than "Pleasant >Valley Sunday", as the liner notes in one of The >Monkees' box sets >claims that Boyce and Hart were at least partly >inspired to write "LTTC" >after listening to "Paperback Writer". > >By the way, you made some very solid points about >Andy Bopp in your >reply to Kerry Kompost. > > >Greg Sager