Nah, I don't think anyone on this board (least of all me) sees extolling the Stones as a putdown of other bands. I'm sure most people here love all of 'em for various reasons, at various times to varying degrees. Rob www.splitsville.com >----- ------- Original Message ------- ----- >From: :audities@smoe.org >To: audities@smoe.org >Sent: Fri, 13 May 2005 10:23:15 > >I don't understand why a thread about the Stones >has to lead to a bunch of >"What about the ... ?" posts. Honestly, I don't see >how extolling the merits >(or lack thereof) of the Stones constitutes a >putdown of the Kinks or the >Who. > >For the record, I love all three bands. I love the >Beatles, too. I don't see >anything mutually exclusive about their fan bases. >Talking about the Stones >no more implicitly insults the Kinks or the Who >than talking about Silver >Sun implicitly insults Admiral Twin or the Shazam. > >As my dear mother used to say to us boys when we >were in the midst of yet >another bout of sibling warfare, "You're all >different, but I love you all >the same." > > >Gregory Sager