smoe.org mailing lists
ivan@stellysee.de
| From | rghwales@writeme.com |
| Subject | Re: Least fave beatles |
| Date | Thu, 05 Nov 2009 11:21:47 -0500 |
[Part 1 text/plain us-ascii (2.2 kilobytes)]
(View Text in a separate window)
Oooo...This is just like incest: a game the whole family can play.
PPM: Do You Want To Know A Secret
WTB: Till There Was You
HDN: I'm Happy Just To Dance With You (under protest. I love this song just slightly less then the others)
BFS: Mr Moonlight
H: Act Naturally
RS: Michelle
R: Yellow Submarine (Which I dont hate at all)
SPLHCB: Within You Without You
MMT: The Fool On The Hill (I dont hate it. Just never a fav)
TWA: Wild Honey Pie
AR: Sun King
LIB: Maggie Mae
A few years ago after a poll in Britain labelled "Ob La Di Ob La da" the worst song ever recorded I wrote the following:
"Recently some British poll has proclaimed The Beatles "Ob-la-di, Ob-la-da" the worst song ever recorded. In many ways this hardly seems fair. "Ob-la-di, Ob-la-da" wouldn't even make the Top 5 worst songs the Beatles ever wrote, the Top 10 worst songs McCartney ever wrote, or the Top 10 worst tracks the Beatles ever recorded. Add if you were going to single out "Ob-la-di" you would have to go after its near cousin "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" as well. The two song are very much of a kind, and Lord knows McCartney has tried to rewrite the damn things every couple of years to sometimes disastrous effect (remember "Ballroom Dancing"?)
"Bottom 5 worst Beatle Songs Ever Written:
#5. "Don't Bother Me": I almost feel bad picking on little Georgie here, but he was obviously still learning how to construct a song at this point. And failing miserably.
#4. "Do You Want To Know A Secret": Too simple and infantile to be taken seriously, right?
#3. "You Know My Name (Look Up The Number)": Sure, its just a lark, but its a long, boring, repetitive, self-indulgent lark.
#2. "Within You, Without You": Maybe its fabulous when you are stoned. It certainly isn't when you're sober.
#1. "Michelle": C'mon!! Its not even close! Nothing else the Beatles ever did was this cloying. Paul singing in French?!? Makes you want to set fire to him...admit it!
And I was able to do this without bringing "Revolution 9" into the mix.
Turn Me On Dead Man! "
The only thing I'd change today is I think I was too hard on "Don't Bother Me". It has the charm of a big awkward but good natured oaf.
Rich Horton
=
For assistance, please contact
the smoe.org administrators.